A number of people have commented on the lack (or perceived lack) of tanks and healers for PUG groups. I have a 70 protection warrior, a 70 holy priest, and a 70 paladin who has gear for both healing and tanking (though I prefer tanking on her). Heck, if someone needs DPS I can bring my hunter. Why don’t I do more pick up groups?
I have no strong objection to PUGs in principle. I don’t mind playing with people I don’t know. Despite all the fun-suckers out there, there are a large number of good people who play WoW. I can live with running into the occasional jerk. Having a group of random people sync up and work well together is a lot of fun. Meeting new people can be great. There are plenty of opportunities for me to join a PUG group.
That being said, I haven’t joined a PUG in weeks, edging up into months. Why not?
First is simply time. On a normal weeknight I might play for up to five hours, 1-2 hours when I get home from work and 3 after the kids are in bed. For those first two hours I pretty much have to be able to drop what I’m doing at any point, so I do my Auction House scan, do as many dailies as I can stand, or generally putter around. I can’t run an instance during that time. Therefore the time I might be available for running PUGs is a maximum of 3 hours per night. If I need that time for farming mats, or getting gold, or grinding rep I’m not available to PUG.
This moves me on to my second reason for not doing PUGs. When I log in in the evening and actually have the time and inclination to run something, it’s rare that there isn’t a friend/guild member looking for a group. Why would I spurn someone I know for a random stranger? I have no lack of premade groups to join. It’s more fun to run with friends or at least with people you’ll probably get to run with again. There is a sense of camaraderie. You know what jokes are appropriate and which topics to avoid. If someone’s having an off night (or wins every single drop), it’s not a big deal - you’ll have your own chances to screw up and win big.
Third comes the sheer economics of PUGing. Last night I ran Heroic Sethekk to help get our 70 druid his epic flight form. We tried to skip a few too many mobs, screwed up on some pulls, and so on - nothing unusual for a new instance and a different than usual group makeup. My repair bills were about 25g. I didn’t have any gear drops and my total coin/grey drops were about 8g. It cost me 17g to do that run, not counting the gold I missed out on getting by not spending that time doing dailies. This was with a good solid group of people I know. I can’t imagine that most PUGs would wipe much less and the time commitment is roughly the same. Every time I PUG I can count on it costing me roughly 20g with a good group. Even if loot drops for me there is a far greater chance of a ninja looter with the lack of accountability in a PUG.
So why would I PUG? It takes time I don’t have, keeps me from spending time with friends, and costs me money. I’d like to meet more people but I already have about all the online friends I can keep up with. Our guild isn’t looking for new recruits. What’s in it for me?